As we’ve seen across our recent portfolio scans, properties with the highest repeat visitation scores—especially among high-net-worth family office travelers—correlate less with maximized ADR and more with integrity in pricing transparency. Ethical lapses like drip pricing or hidden fee layering may pad RevPAR in the short run, but they erode what we call Cultural Alpha—that hard-to-price but easy-to-lose combination of brand goodwill, intergenerational guest loyalty, and premium cultural partnerships.
This is particularly relevant to our ongoing conversations with prominent art families in Europe and Asia. These families, many of whom are considering licensing artwork to hospitality operators as part of a broader cultural asset deployment strategy, frequently cite guest experience integrity and brand alignment as more important than RevPAR deltas. As noted in Art Collecting Today, “Art is more than an object—it’s a signal of intent. When placed in public domains, it asks: who are we aligning with?” This ethos translates directly into how we view hotel pricing behavior.
There is an analogy here to portfolio theory. A short-term boost from aggressive overbooking or loyalty program manipulation may mirror a high-beta trade—profitable in the moment, but with asymmetric tail risk. Reputation loss, social media backlash, and OTA delisting are the real drawdowns in hospitality today. And like toxic assets on a balance sheet, these reputational wounds are hard to offload.
As Management of Art Galleries reminds us: “Trust is a longer-term asset than capital—it compounds slowly, but deteriorates fast.” Hospitality operators should heed this. A single pricing misstep, when magnified across digital channels, can erode years of brand equity. Our own AHA scores (Authenticity, Hospitality, Artfulness) include ethical pricing behavior as a leading sub-factor—because discerning cultural partners, especially those in the art and design community, now demand it.
Revenue managers operating under pressure may push boundaries around rate manipulation, overbooking, or loyalty-based sleight-of-hand. But in doing so, they’re not just risking chargebacks or refund requests—they’re triggering a deeper kind of instability: psychological churn. As we noted in our comparative analysis of conversion-led vs. conviction-led hotels in Asia, properties with high AHA scores tend to perform better in guest retention, staff longevity, and community partnerships—even when their ADR lags marginally behind “algorithm-led” competitors.
This lines up with what Vanderholm observed in the misuse of upselling and cross-selling. When incentives are misaligned—when staff bonuses are tied to extraction, not elevation—trust breaks down. Guests may not always remember the room number, but they’ll remember if they felt tricked.
Bay Street has been engaged in ongoing dialogues with foundations representing the heirs of modernist and postmodernist masters. In one case, a multi-generational family with custodianship over a body of photography from the Bauhaus era expressed clear disinterest in working with any operator whose brand had a track record of fee ambiguity. “Our name cannot be placed next to broken trust,” one family member put it plainly. This is where revenue management and cultural capital intersect.
Transparency isn’t just about regulation—it’s about philosophical alignment. And in a world where the next phase of hospitality differentiation may come from aesthetic affiliation—who you hang, whose music you play, which literary voices you amplify—then revenue managers need to start thinking like stewards, not just tacticians.
Connor Vanderholm’s essay isn’t just an exposé—it’s an invitation. An invitation for GMs, DOSs, and RM professionals to evolve past the myopic KPIs of yesterday and embrace a framework where yield stability, trust equity, and cultural alignment sit in harmony.
Bay Street encourages operators and allocators alike to:
If yield is the game, then ethics is the metagame. And those who play both well—just like the great collectors and gallerists—tend to win where it matters most: in memory, loyalty, and legacy.
...
Bay Street Hospitality is a diversified hotel fund series for allocators seeking quant-driven exposure across top countries, operators, and hotel tiers. The fund targets a diversified portfolio in both high-growth emerging markets and stable developed markets, optimizing risk-adjusted returns. The leadership provides structured equity and pivotal strategic guidance to hotel-related investments. The fund establishes joint ventures with best-in-class partners, focusing on deal flexibility, currency considerations, tax efficiency, and clear exit strategies.
