LEAVE US YOUR MESSAGE
contact us

Hi! Please leave us your message or call us at 510-858-1921

Thank you! Your submission has been received!

Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form

9
May

📈 Negotiating with the Bay Score

Last Updated
I
May 9, 2025

At Bay Street Hospitality, term negotiation is data-driven. Using the Bay Score framework, the fund dynamically adjusts its negotiation position—ideal, fallback, and dealbreaker—based on the actual score profile of each deal.

Why Generic Legal Language Hurts Investors

Traditional Term Sheet vs Bay Street Method

• One-size-fits-all clauses → Terms adjusted based on IRR, AHA, ESG, etc.

• Fixed fallback language → Dynamic 'ideal/fallback/dealbreaker' based on metrics

• Opaque risk-sharing → Transparent tradeoffs based on Bay Score quartiles

• Static reps and covenants → Terms adapt based on Sponsor Score and Region Risk

Structure of the Dynamic Negotiation Playbook

Bay Street’s negotiation protocol uses a three-tiered approach per clause:

• Ideal Term = Highest protection when Bay Score is <70

• Fallback = Standard when Bay Score is 70–89

• Dealbreaker = Minimum baseline only acceptable for 90+

Each clause is linked to:
• Bay Score (composite strength)
• AHA / IRR (return profile)
• BMRI / LSD (macro + exit risk)
• Sponsor Quality

Example Clauses with Dynamic Settings

Clause: Waterfall Distribution
Bay Score < 70 → 9% Pref + Full Catch-Up | 70–89 → 8% Pref, 50/50 | 90+ → 6% Pref, No Catch-Up

Clause: Brand Termination Rights
BMRI < 40 → LP veto rights | 40–70 → LP consultation | >70 → Brand locked-in

Clause: Exit Control
LSD > 3.5% → LP Exit Priority | <3.5% → Sponsor Exit Call

Negotiation Strategy Based on Bay Score Quartile

• Q1 (90–100) → More flexibility; modest alignment tradeoffs

• Q2 (80–89) → Moderate stance; ensure IRR is protected

• Q3 (70–79) → Conservative stance; stronger fallback clauses

• Q4 (<70) → Tight protection; enforce strict pref and controls

In Practice: Negotiating with Precision

• Marriott REIT (Bay Score 87): Accept 7% pref, standard exit, no co-invest clawbacks

• Portugal ground-up (Bay Score 93): Lower pref, sponsor gets flexibility on promote

• Sri Lanka boutique (Bay Score 64, BMRI 71): 10% pref, IRR floor, FX hedge, co-invest escrow

Benefits for Investors and Sponsors

Institutional LPs

• Avoid overpaying for high-risk deals

• Build term sheets tied to quantitative logic

• Increase trust in underwriting discipline

Sponsors

• Negotiate faster with logic-based arguments

• Win better terms for stronger assets

• Build repeatable structuring templates

How the Playbook Is Maintained

The Bay Street Terminal dynamically generates negotiation language based on:

• Bay Score quartile

• Region risk (BMRI)

• Exit delay risk (LSD)

• Sponsor attributes

Conclusion: A Smarter Way to Negotiate

In hospitality, the line between return and regret is in the details. By applying a quantified negotiation playbook informed by the Bay Score system, Bay Street ensures that every investor clause—exit rights, fees, controls—is grounded in data, not anecdotes.

Dynamic alignment = stronger protections, smarter capital deployment, and long-term trust with institutional partners.

...

Latest posts
16
Sep
Quantamental Hospitality Investing
The Nickel Hotel Opens in Charleston — A Lesson in Opportunity Zones and Cultural Alpha
September 16, 2025

Charleston’s newest boutique hotel, The Nickel Hotel, is more than just another luxury opening on King Street. For Bay Street, it is a case study in how hospitality investments can align fiscal engineering, place-based revitalization, and cultural resonance into a defensible moat.

Continue Reading
16
Sep
Quantamental Hospitality Investing
Scarcity as Moat: Why Institutional Capital Is Entering the Ultraluхury Hotel Space
September 16, 2025

For years, the ultraluxury hotel niche — properties with fewer than 100 keys, often perched on irreplaceable clifftops, vineyards, or historic estates — has been the preserve of family offices and high-net-worth individuals. But as Thomas Brown, CEO of San Francisco–based Ad Altius, argues, the tide is turning. Institutional capital is creeping in, lured not by scale but by scarcity.

Continue Reading
16
Sep
Quantamental Hospitality Investing
Designing With Cultural Reverence: Wellness Hotels as Cultural Assets, Not Appropriations
September 16, 2025

Luxury hospitality has entered a new phase where “wellness” is no longer a bolt-on spa but a full design philosophy rooted in culture, place, and longevity. As Kathy Colon of Nova Lux DR Properties argues, the challenge for developers isn’t just creating beautiful properties — it’s creating ones that belong.

Continue Reading

Unlock the Playbook

Download the Quantamental Approach to Investor Protection, Alignment & Alpha Creation Playbook
Thank you!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Are you an allocator or reporter exploring deal structuring in hospitality?
Request a 30-minute strategy briefing
Get in touch